Auto ยท head-to-head
GEICO vs Progressive vs State Farm
Verified rates, discount stacks, bundle math, J.D. Power positioning. The default 3-way for most US drivers.
GEICO, Progressive, State Farm, USAA, and Allstate compared on monthly cost, discount stacks, and coverage. Plus verified cheapest carriers in 40+ states. The average driver saves $500+/yr by switching once a year.
Average switcher saves
$500+/yr
By quoting 3โ5 carriers at renewal
Updated May 10, 2026 ยท What changed: Rebuilt the hub with HubHero + QuickPaths to match the canonical /earn hub layout. Wired EngineInsuranceEmbed (feature-flagged). State grid is now auto-driven from getAllStateSlugs() โ all 40+ verified states. Sub-cluster grid expanded to all 20 deep guides (was 11).
For each carrier we verified five fields against rate filings and published disclosures in May 2026: (1) baseline monthly cost for a clean-record driver with full coverage, (2) the discount stack available, (3) bundle discount percentage, (4) telematics program terms (specifically whether the program can RAISE rates, as Progressive Snapshot can), and (5) claims service rating from J.D. Power. For state-by-state cheapest carriers, every figure is cross-verified against at least two of MoneyGeek, NerdWallet, Bankrate, ValuePenguin, U.S. News, Insurify, or The Zebra (2026 carrier analyses), plus the state's DMV or insurance commissioner page for minimum requirements. Best-in-category rankings reflect what kind of driver benefits most: clean record favors GEICO; high-risk profile favors Progressive; military favors USAA; bundling favors State Farm; telematics rewards favor Allstate. We do not rank by partner payout โ USAA is at the top despite being a non-affiliate option because it's genuinely the cheapest for eligible drivers.
Insurers raise rates quietly between renewal cycles. Quoting 3โ5 carriers at every renewal takes 30 minutes and is the single highest-ROI thing on this hub.
Avg US premium
$1,771
per year, full coverage
Avg switch saving
$500+
per year
Bundle leader
State Farm: 23% off
Auto + home, ~$1,010/yr saved
Each card opens the head-to-head with monthly cost ranges, discount stacks, telematics, and J.D. Power claims rating.
Cheapest baseline ($120โ$180/mo). Fastest online quote-to-bind. Best for clean records.
Browse category$130โ$200/mo. Specialty in high-risk pricing โ competitive after accidents, tickets, DUI.
Browse category$140โ$210/mo. Largest US agent network. Bundle discount stack 10โ25%.
Browse category$100โ$160/mo โ cheapest in our table. Military, veteran, or family eligibility required.
Browse category$150โ$220/mo. Drivewise telematics + accident forgiveness on standard policies.
Browse categoryEstimate the discount stack each carrier would offer you, plus expected monthly savings.
Browse categoryState-specific guides with verified May 2026 minimums, average costs, and cheapest carriers per state. 50 states covered today; remainder added monthly.
All entries verified May 2026 against state DMV / insurance-commissioner sources.
Twenty deep-dive guides for specific driver profiles, life events, and edge cases. Each verified May 2026.
Min coverage from $43/mo, full coverage from $97/mo. 8 discount stacks worked.
Browse category$4,515/yr on parent policy vs $9,825/yr own. Cheapest carrier by state.
Browse categoryWhere The Hartford and AARP plans actually save money โ and where they don't.
Browse category+$3,017/yr avg increase. Progressive cheapest. SR-22 explained.
Browse category+34โ43% rate avg, 3โ5 yr surcharge. GEICO has free forgiveness.
Browse category$3,000/yr avg post-DUI + $15โ$50 filing. Progressive specialty cheapest.
Browse category+113% premium avg. Nationwide cheapest. 4 states ban credit pricing.
Browse categoryMultiple tickets, lapses, accidents โ non-standard markets that still take you.
Browse categoryHow long the surcharge lasts and which insurers don't penalize a 30-day lapse.
Browse categoryLiability for drivers who don't own a car โ required for SR-22 in many states.
Browse categoryAvg 15% / $869/yr saved. State Farm leads at 23% / $1,010/yr.
Browse categoryVerified percentages from GEICO/State Farm/Allstate/Progressive/USAA. Stacking math.
Browse category$6โ$94/mo endorsement closes the Period-1 gap. CA SB 371 cut UM/UIM 94% Jan 2026.
Browse categoryAgreed-value vs stated-value. Hagerty, Grundy, American Collectors compared.
Browse categoryEVs cost ~26% more to insure. Battery replacement, repair networks, EV-specific carriers.
Browse categoryWhen the dealer's gap is a rip-off and the standalone option that's 80% cheaper.
Browse categoryAAA vs your insurer's add-on vs Allstate Motor Club โ true 5-year cost.
Browse categoryUS auto policies don't cover Mexico. Carrier breakdown for cross-border driving.
Browse categoryVerified May 2026 minimums in one matrix. HI doubled, FL repeals PIP July 2026.
Browse category$5,314 avg property damage, $57K avg medical. 3 worked scenarios.
Browse categoryVerified May 2026 rates and discount stacks for the most common matchups.
Auto ยท head-to-head
Verified rates, discount stacks, bundle math, J.D. Power positioning. The default 3-way for most US drivers.
Auto ยท head-to-head
If you're military, veteran, or family โ USAA is usually 46% below national average. Here's where GEICO and Progressive close the gap.
We track every major carrier weekly. When rates move, when a state changes its minimums, or when a new discount becomes available โ we send the update.
No spam โ unsubscribe in one click, any time.
Disclosure: WalletGrower may earn a commission when you sign up for products through our links. This never affects our rankings or recommendations. Premiums vary by ZIP code, driving record, vehicle, coverage selection, and credit score (in 46 states) โ quotes from your own carrier are the only authoritative number.
Editorial independence: We do not rank by partner payout. USAA, which is not an affiliate partner, is ranked top for military families because itโs genuinely the cheapest for eligible drivers.